Truth, Justice, and the dangers of teaching Science

Posted July 10th, 2012 by Jen Bryant

Ringside 1925We are fascinated with crime, police investigations and high-profile trials. I’m not sure why, but despite all of the evidence to the contrary, perhaps we need to believe that sometimes justice prevails, truth wins, the bad guys get their due. I’ve written novels about two of these famous trials, but although they took place just ten years apart, generated a great deal of media attention, and are still used as examples in laws schools across the U.S., they differed in very significant ways.

Inherit the Wind

Whereas the Lindbergh baby kidnapping trial lasted six long weeks in the winter of 1935, included a murder victim (Charles Lindbergh’s 20-month-old son, “little Charlie”), an accused man (Bruno Richard Hauptmann), and a laundry list of circumstantial evidence, the Scopes Evolution trial was almost purely a tactical, intellectual, and often emotional debate between William Jennings Bryan (a fiery orator and three-time presidential candidate), and Clarence Darrow, the most successful trial lawyer in the country.

The “defendant,” John T. Scopes was a young, first-year high school teacher and a football coach, who agreed to be arrested (a formality, he was never actually detained) so that the Butler Act, a Tennessee law which forbade the teaching of “any theory that denies the story of divine creation as taught by the Bible and to teach instead that man was descended from a lower order of animals” could be challenged in a courtroom.

Scopes Trial MarkerThe job of a novelist is as much about making decisions (Who will tell the story? Will there be more than one narrator? How much back story will I provide? What are the ages, genders and occupations of my fictional characters? Will the real/ historical characters speak and/or interact with the fictional ones? etc.) as it is about crafting language. Today, June 10th, marks the 87th anniversary of Day One of the eight-day trial in Dayton, Tennessee. And even though Ringside 1925: Views from the Scopes Trial was published in 2008, I often find myself riffling through my research notes and files, still fascinated by the “crime” of teaching science, the media frenzy that surrounded that hot, smoky courtroom, and the consistently inconsistent nature of the word “justice.”

Are you fascinated by famous cases, too? Which ones and why? Leave a comment below—and in the meantime, enjoy these links:

The Scopes Trial Museum

Oprah’s Book Club Books for Y/A

Teaching ideas


 

Copyright © 2006- Jen Bryant. All rights reserved. No images or content on these pages
may be reproduced or republished in any form without permission. Site designed by Winding Oak.